MBTMens Modena III Leather Textile Shoes

I've been wearing MBT shoes since 2013 and they were so good I could wear them without orthotics because they were so supportive. My first pair lasted 5 years. As a point of context, I would have to get shoes every 9 months to 1 year before MBT. These shoes have started squeaking within a week of wearing them. My previous pair lasted 3 years. Time will tell if I will have to repair them or replace them in the coming months. They're comfortable and supportive or they would get zero stars.

Not very comfortable. are very loose and move around a lot, even coming off on occasion